Bypass Trust Problems: Why Pre-2018 Trusts Cost Heirs $300K+

Most families who set up a Bypass Trust, sometimes called an AB Trust or Credit Shelter Trust, did everything right. These structures were brilliant tax-savers when the federal estate tax exemption was only a few million dollars. But today, with exemptions at $15 million per person, those same trusts can quietly drain wealth instead of protecting it. 

If your estate plan was drafted before 2018, there's a good chance it still follows the old playbook. These common bypass trust problems could be creating avoidable tax exposure for your heirs, sometimes substantial. It's a costly mistake that affects families who believe their plans are still current. 

The Core Bypass Trust Problem: Loss of Step-Up in Basis

Bypass trusts were designed so each spouse could "use" their estate tax exemption. When one spouse passed away, half the estate went into the bypass trust and half stayed with the survivor, effectively doubling the amount protected from estate tax. The logic was sound at the time. 

Then Congress introduced portability in 2011, allowing the surviving spouse to use both exemptions without splitting assets. The bypass structure stopped being essential for most families. But millions of existing trusts were never updated. 

That's where bypass trust problems begin. Assets inside that old trust become frozen in time. They don't receive a second step-up in basis when the surviving spouse passes away, leaving heirs with significant capital gains exposure. Step-up in basis allows heirs to inherit appreciated assets at current market value rather than original purchase price, potentially eliminating decades of capital gains taxes. 

When bypass trust provisions prevent that second step-up, families lose this powerful benefit on half their estate. For families with appreciated real estate or long-held investments, that difference can easily reach hundreds of thousands of dollars. 

How Bypass Trusts Cost Heirs Six Figures in Taxes 

Most heirs today aren't losing money to estate tax, they're losing it to capital-gains tax. 

Imagine a family home that has appreciated over decades. When the first spouse dies, half goes into the bypass trust and gets one step-up in basis. When the surviving spouse eventually passes years later, that trust portion doesn't get a second step-up - it remains locked at the value from years earlier. 

Meanwhile, the half that stayed with the surviving spouse does get a fresh step-up at the second death. When children inherit and sell, half the estate sells tax-free thanks to the recent step-up, while the other half generates substantial taxable gains from its outdated basis. 

The result? A six-figure check to the IRS on assets that could have transferred tax-free under modern structures. That money could have supported children's futures, funded charitable gifts, or built generational wealth. Instead, it disappears because of outdated trust language. 

Why Old Planning No Longer Works 

Many families assume if a plan worked once, it works forever. Estate planning doesn't operate that way. Tax law evolves constantly, but documents don't automatically update. 

A bypass trust perfectly designed in 2005 may now conflict with how modern tax code treats married couples. Portability, higher exemptions, and changing state laws have reshaped planning. What made sense under a $2 million exemption becomes problematic under $15 million. 

Even skilled professionals can face coordination gaps. An attorney might have drafted the trust flawlessly, but without updated financial modeling, families don't see the hidden tax drag building. The legal documents remain valid but no longer serve the family's best interests. 

Strategic Considerations for Modernizing Your Trust 

There are proven strategies to resolve bypass trust problems, but the right approach depends on your circumstances. Modern planning focuses on flexibility, simplicity, and tax efficiency across generations. 

The first consideration is trust structure: whether a restatement or modification can make the trust revocable and aligned with current exemptions.  

Tax modeling forms the second piece. Advisors can project the difference between keeping your current structure and modernizing it, often revealing a significant dollar gap. These projections account for appreciation rates, holding periods, and tax brackets. 

Professional coordination is essential. When your estate attorney, CPA, and financial advisor work together, legal documents, account titling, and tax projections stay aligned. Timing creates the final constraint - all changes must happen while the surviving spouse is alive. Once the second death occurs, the trust becomes irrevocable and basis problems become permanent. 

When Bypass Trust Problems Hit Hardest 

Certain situations create outsized exposure to bypass trust problems. Families with significant real estate holdings, closely held businesses, or large investment portfolios face the steepest capital gains impact when assets have been frozen at outdated basis levels for years or even decades. 

Blended families deserve special attention. Old bypass trust language can create unintended consequences: assets may flow to children from a first marriage while leaving a current spouse with less than intended, or vice versa. A trust designed to "protect the kids" in 2008 might now be protecting them from inheriting anything substantial after taxes eat away at the frozen basis portion. These family dynamics require careful review to ensure the trust still reflects your actual intentions. 

Community-property state residents face a different challenge entirely. These states normally offer favorable basis treatment for married couples, but outdated bypass trust splits can actually override those state-level advantages. The result is losing tax benefits at both the federal and state level, a compounding effect that makes the tax hit even more painful. 

Take Action While You Still Have Options 

Bypass trust problems rarely surface until it's too late, usually after the surviving spouse passes and heirs begin inheritance. At that point, the trust is irrevocable and tax damage is permanent. 

A focused consultation with your estate attorney and financial advisor can quickly identify whether your plan fits today's tax environment. Look for trusts drafted before 2018, and pay attention to language around bypass trusts, family trusts, credit shelter trusts, or AB trusts. 

If updates are needed, making them now preserves not just dollars, but family clarity and peace of mind. In the video above, I walk through a side-by-side comparison of two families with identical wealth but dramatically different tax outcomes based solely on their trust structure, show you exactly what to check in your trust documents, and explain how portability changed the planning landscape for married couples. 

Ready to protect your legacy with confidence? 

Let’s start a conversation. Book a free initial call and learn how we can help you protect what you’ve built and secure a stronger financial future for your loved ones.